Betsy Wolfe Takes PEOPLE Inside Opening Night of Broadway's '& Juliet' — See the Exclusive Photos!

"It's just one of the most beautiful stories I've ever been able to tell," Betsy Wolfe tells PEOPLE of the new musical, which opened Thursday night on Broadway

Betsy Wolfe is coming back to Broadway in style!

After back-to-back Broadway and Off-Broadway shows before the COVID-19 pandemic shut down the Great White Way, Wolfe, 40, returns to the New York stage in & Juliet, the new pop musical that flips Shakespeare on its head by way of a pop score of radio hits by songwriter Max Martin.